
A Conservative minster who clashed with Margaret Thatcher is reported to have said:
“The trouble with Margaret is that when she speaks without thinking, she says what she thinks.”
Seven words
In an extensive interview for Woman’s Own magazine in September 1987 Thatcher said what she thought. In response to over 50 questions, her answers extended to almost 10,000 words. Seven specific words though have echoed down the years:
“there is no such thing as society”.
For critics of Thatcherism, these words continue to provide the most damning evidence of its malign influence. They encapsulate the worst excess of the 1980s ‘me first’ culture that I and my student friends professed to hate.
Nearly 40 years on though I am not so sure. In fact what she said seems to me to contain important truths in grave danger of being forgotten today.
What did she actually say?
The context of these famous seven words were:
“[too many] people are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing!
There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people, and people look to themselves first. It is our duty to look after ourselves and then also to help look after our neighbour, and life is a reciprocal business and people have got the entitlements too much in mind without the obligations …
There is no such thing as society. There is a living tapestry of men and women and people and the beauty of that tapestry and the quality of our lives will depend upon how much each of us is prepared to take responsibility for ourselves and each of us prepared to turn round and help by our own efforts those who are unfortunate.”
Taking responsibility for ourselves
The news today is awash with stories and opinions about what ‘they’ – ‘the state’ or ‘the government’ or ‘society’; whatever name you give to that amorphous force supposed to help and sustain us without any effort on our own part – should be doing for ‘us’.
It seems we have a seemingly never-ending narrative that “something has gone wrong, and someone else should do something” about it.
Turbocharged by the experience of the pandemic, when people were – quite rightly – protected by ‘they’ from a deadly virus and financially supported, there is now a growing sense that pervades Britain that people should be protected from losing out in any way. A belief that ‘they’ can, and should, fix everything for ‘us’, whether by rebate, exemption or recompense.
The risk is that the game of life played this way overwhelmingly descends into a ceaseless struggle to obtain dispensation, mitigation and support, from ‘they’, for everything.
And, in the course of that, people’s sense of agency, and notion that they themselves have some responsibility for facing, and overcoming, the challenges of life, can evaporate.
Taking responsibility for helping others
Welfare state protections are a hugely important safety net for those who need them. Britain is justly proud of the welfare system it has built over the last 80 years.
But there is a risk, and a balance to be struck. The risk is that the existence of the welfare state undermines, rather than supports, a caring culture of people taking responsibility for helping others.
Prior to the existence of the welfare state, people had to rely on each other – on family, social and community ties that they had invested in and built up – as it was the only safety net there was.
The ability of people today to rely on the welfare state is all well and good as far as it goes, but what if family, social and community ties wither as a consequence? If the state is expected to care for everyone, what does this do to people’s willingness to help other people, even those in their own family?
Mrs Thatcher at The Vine
What got me thinking about what Mrs Thatcher actually said is my experiences at The Vine, a community gathering held at Streatham Baptist Church on Wednesday nights. It’s a place where those struggling most in life can come in for faith, food, company, games and an always inventive quiz.
Even at The Vine though there is no such thing as a ‘free lunch’. Those attending must exercise agency and take some responsibility for themselves. They must get themselves there on time. The aim is to work against the dangerous creep of the passive receiving of resources and to seek human engagement. Everyone coming has to engage with others in some form, as far as they are able. And all are encouraged to help out, put tables and chairs away and serve together.
The volunteers who cook the food, chat, play games and deliver the messages of faith with those coming through the door, are not agents of ‘they’. There is no state funding, no contract delivered, no strategic plan. They are ‘us’, people with handwritten name badges who have taken the responsibility to come together on a dark weeknight to deliver connection and sustenance to others.
This is the ‘human tapestry’ that Margaret Thatcher spoke of. It is woven – by people, for people – and it happens in deepest Streatham every Wednesday night.
Let’s not contract out all of our sense of responsibility towards others. And let’s recognise the beauty of the tapestry we can weave together.
Jonathan Thomas is a Senior Fellow at the Social Market Foundation think tank.
Read about The Vine: Keeping social action salty and The contributory principle: everyone can do something for others
Discover more from Grace + Truth
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Thank you. There are certainly valid insights here. It’s true that Thatcher’s words have long been misquoted. She was correctly denying that an abstraction called ‘society’ is an entity that can act and that ‘it’ can provide for ‘us’. But the named actors in her particular fusion of traditional conservative and neo-liberal vision are only individuals, families and the state, a much denuded social ontology. The Vine already seems to belie that; it’s a distinctive form of association, not simply a training school for individual enterprise. In fact we are and need to be members of a dense mesh of multiple communities, associations and networks by which we exercise shared agency and solidarity, alongside our individual agency. Thatcher’s reference to a ‘living tapestry of men and women and people’ seems to allude obliquely to this mesh, beyond individuals and families. But she then undermines the point by adding that ‘the beauty of that tapestry and the quality of our lives will depend upon how much each of us is prepared to take responsibility for ourselves and each of us prepared to turn round and help by our own efforts those who are unfortunate’: that is not solidarity or shared agency, but charity. I think the article understates the extent to which many people still still live out such solidarity, indeed they do so in new and creative ways, in spite of the enormous counter-pressures of individualism and statism. But I think what I most miss is a recognition that the greatest cause of both those distorting extremes is the dominant form of capitalism which simultaneously atomises social relations and weakens intermediate communities, and creates the compensating need for a powerful regulatory state to police those consequences. And that was the form of capitalism that Thatcher championed: her neo-liberalism triumphed over her traditional conservatism. From Jonathan Chaplin
LikeLike
Very interesting and thoughtful Jonathan.
My piece was about how I had personally connected my observations of helping at The Vine with thinking about Thatcher’s famous (mis) quote.
It was certainly not meant as a wider analysis or defence of Thatcherism’s broader and deeper effects on the subject matter, and how the things she talked about played out in practice under her governments, which you are clearly expert on. Thanks for giving your insights.
LikeLike
The quote was not the problem.. everybody on left or right has tried to articulate a communitarian philosophy in which people have a balance of rights / privileges and responsibilities, and where individuals and communities interact. The problem with Thatcherism was the policies mainly the neo liberal economic ones, which placed economic risk upon the individual, especially the poorest, and transferred wealth from the people to the plutocrats. On top of that was the ideology and scapegoating that blamed “shirkers” for their own poverty.
LikeLike
I think the problem was that Mrs Thatcher didn’t realise that people exist inside of institutions (whether actual, or imaginary) which are much more than the sum of their parts.
Some of these instutional parts include bricks and mortar, people, history, beliefs, rituals, laws, collective organisation and yes (depite her wishes) the state. The irony is that she & Heath were products of the Conservative Party, an institution if there ever was one, having to adjust to a post-colonial World.
The way that she used state (publicly) owned resources to regressively redistribute resources was also a product of her own background (she believed that everyone aspired to be part of a “share-owning democracy” even though this led to private sector monopolies for essential resources such as water). Her policies remain largely responsible for the housing mess (and the subsequent homelessness we still find ourselves in.
LikeLike
I think that desroying Sunday as a shared day of rest was an example of Thatcher’s neo-liberalialism eclipsing her social conservatism, damaging the ‘tapestry’ incalculably.
LikeLiked by 1 person